An organ in honour of College Street Baptist Church parishioners who gave their lives in the First World War was unveiled on January 17, 1926, by Brigadier-General C.H. Mitchell.
Around 1960 the congregation at 506 College Street dwindled and the church closed. The building was sold to the Portuguese Seventh-day Adventist Church. In 2007, the building was sold to a developer and turned into residential homes. There are no records of what happened to the organ.