A tablet in memory of Queen Street Methodist parishioners who fell in the First World War was unveiled on October 26, 1919.
In 1923, the Methodist churches on Euclid Avenue and Queen Street were joined as Queen Street Methodist, and two years later, as Queen Street United at 423 Queen Street W. The church amalgamated with College Street United Church in 1974, and retained that name in the College Street building. It is not known what happened to the plaque.