In 1924, the Women’s Association presented an organ honouring Alhambra Avenue Presbyterian Church parishioners who served in the First World War.
The congregation at 1573 Bloor Street West joined the United Church in 1925. In 1970, Alhambra Avenue United Church united with High Park Avenue Methodist Church to form High Park-Alhambra United Church in the High Park Avenue building. The congregation closed and it is not known what happened to the organ.