This Honour Roll was originally located in Mitchell United Church which was built in 1868 on land donated by the Mitchell family in the 1840s. Mitchell United Church consolidated with Mono Mills United Church to form Trillium United Church in 2016 at the former Mono Mills United Church location.
This style of an Honour Roll was designed by A.J. Casson when he worked at Sampson-Matthews, a prominent midtown Toronto lithography and commercial art company. The Honour Roll was created after the Second World War and it is not known when it was unveiled.